Even with the hue and cry with respect to the Bank of America fee, to a thinking person it should immediately become clear that it is the diatribe of Senator Durbin that is the story here, not the fee.
As to the fee, Bank of America is doing what banks do. They are simply reacting to the changes brought about by Dodd-Frank. This law has limited the amount that banks can charge retailers for debit transactions so they are simply moving those charges directly to customers instead. One of the fundamentals of free-market enterprise is that when laws effect an impact to a company's bottom line, it doesn't simply absorb the additional costs and go on its merry way. I'm sure that's what Senator Dodd and Congressman Frank thought would happen, but it never does. Instead, companies simply transfer the additional costs, one way or another to customers. As a side note, this principle is also completely lost on many with respect to taxes. One of the great princples of business, immutable and unchangeable is, "businesses do not pay taxes". People do. Those who advocate for business tax increases simply do not understand that businesses will never pay them. They will simply pass those additional costs on to consumers.
And so it is with Bank of America. They do not bear the additional costs incurred to them by Dodd-Frank. They pass those costs along to consumers in the form of the five-dollar fee.
Now, with respect to the diatribe of Senator Durbin. What he said exactly was this,
“Bank of America customers, vote with your feet. Get the heck out of that bank. Find yourself a bank or credit union that won’t gouge you for $5 a month and still will give you a debit card that you can use every single day. What Bank of America has done is an outrage.”
Now some might argue, that this is "the free market at work". Nothing could be farther from the truth. If U.S. Bank were to make such a statement, that would be "free market competition". That would be U.S. Bank saying, "we won't charge you the fee, come to us". But when a sitting Senator, on the floor of the Senate says it, that is something else. Some might argue, that Senator Durbin has his free-speech rights. That is certainly true. He does. He can say what he wants from the floor of the Senate. But one must ask himself, how appropriate is it, for a sitting Senator, on the floor of the Senate to call for a boycott of an American company? We do not send our elected representatives to Washington to berate companies for the way they do business. We send them to Washington to make laws to protect the American people. Nothing more.In the last 50 to 75 years, we have developed a form of government that tries to pick winners and losers. From energy policy, to home ownership, to the foods we eat, government has tried to shape the market place. How has that worked out so far? It is clear that the Federal Government is now over-reaching in yet another dangerous way. The words of Senator Durbin are just the latest example.
No comments:
Post a Comment